Sia, the singer turned film director, discovered herself in some scorching water Friday after critics observed a flaw within the casting for her movie, Music. The mysterious songstress forged Maddie Ziegler, a frequent star in Sia’s work, to play an autistic character. Ziegler just isn’t autistic in actual life.
Advocates instantly picked up on the issue when the trailer dropped. A number of followers expressed their disappointment in Sia’s casting selections by way of Twitter, prompting a heated response from the singer.
Sia tweeted, “I forged 13 neuroatypical individuals, three trans folks, and never as fucking prostitutes or drug addicts however as docs, nurses and singers. Fucking unhappy no one’s even seen the dang film. My coronary heart has at all times been in the correct place”.
An autistic actor responded that any variety of her friends would have been completely satisfied to take the function. Sia then clapped again that perhaps they aren’t excellent actors.
The Problematic Response
It seems as if, as a substitute of acknowledging her mistake, Sia merely doubled down on the stance. In her response, not solely does she dismiss the considerations of incapacity advocates, she manages to insult two different marginalized teams.
She particularly names intercourse staff and addicts in her response, framing them as some sort of undesirable group. Her tweet implies that it’s someway undesirable for actors to play intercourse staff or drug addicts.
This can be a deeply dangerous concept that serves to additional marginalize already marginalized teams. It perpetuates the notion that intercourse staff and addicts are inherently value lower than the remainder of us. Together with the dearth of illustration in the case of her autistic characters, it doesn’t make Sia seem like essentially the most inclusive director leisure has ever seen, which definitely appears to be how she sees herself.
There are higher methods for creators to reply to such criticisms. When incapacity advocates identified problems with Warner Bros.’s adaptation of The Witches, each the studio and the star of the image, Anne Hathaway, responded with deeply empathetic and seemingly honest apologies. Typically, it’s best to not offend one group of individuals after which defend that call with an announcement offending two extra teams of individuals.
It’s true that critics haven’t but truly seen the film, because it doesn’t premiere till February 2021. It’s uncertain, nonetheless, that their views will change because the casting is the issue and never the content material of the movie itself.